View the Mobile Version of M+N

Record Reviews

PVT
Church With No Magic

On third album 'Church With No Magic', the band formerly known as Pivot return with not just a new name but an evolution in sound, writes ANDREW MCMILLEN.

The further you get through Church With No Magic, the less it sounds like 2008’s O Soundtrack My Heart. That album - the band’s final release under the Pivot moniker, before ceding it to an American nu-metal band – stood at the intersection of rock and electronica, forming a remarkable amalgam of the two. Like O Soundtrack My Heart, Church With No Magic opens with a brief instrumental composition (‘Community’), but that’s where the comparison ends. Here, PVT are not just embracing a new name, but an evolution in sound.

‘Light Up Bright Fires’ seethes with twisted synth sounds and ominous, shape-shifting vocals. Yes, vocals. Richard Pike’s voice appears on most of the tracks here; its presence adds an extra layer of melody to the band’s output. The addition of vocals isn’t too surprising, considering the deep, wordless yawns that coloured O Soundtrack’s ‘Sing You Sinners’, yet the range displayed is quite extraordinary. In ‘Crimson Swan’, he favours a slowly-enunciated baritone that rises in line with the swelling instrumentation. In ‘Window’, his sustained delivery forms the central hook. Lyrically, Pike flits between the abstract (“All of God’s mysteries/Left upon my backseat” in ‘Light Up Bright Fires’) and self-affirmed certainties (“I won’t slip/I won’t fall/I won’t change” in ‘Window’). Despite the theologically provocative album title, it’s probably a red herring. “Oh, I subscribed/All our dreams died,” sings Pike in the title track, yet I get the feeling that he chose many of the words for their sounds, not their connotations.

“The latter half of the album ventures deep into experimental electronica, and never quite resurfaces.”

Richard Pike’s brother, Laurence, and Dave Miller complete the trio. Miller is mostly responsible for laptop and synthesiser wrangling, while Richard handles guitar and bass in addition to vocal duties. To attempt to intellectualise Laurence Pike’s drumming, however, is to miss the point entirely. Slotted between the warped electronica of his bandmates, Pike approaches the kit with an unorthodox vision: it’s not so much a rhythmic component as it is a lead instrument. ‘Light Up Bright Fires’ is played so loosely, so off-the-cuff that for the most part, it sounds like one big drum fill. Pike takes the playing of Australia’s best rock drummers - Jeffrey Wegener and Jim White - to an extreme neither of those players envisaged. He lends innovation and uniqueness to every project he’s involved in, but on Church, he exhibits his best work yet. Pike’s stickwork is the most compelling aspect of first single ‘The Quick Mile’, and indeed, most of the tracks here. As a drummer, he’s thrilling, unpredictable and peerless.

The latter half of the album ventures deep into experimental electronica, and never quite resurfaces. A sinister sense of unease pervades ‘Timeless’, which is built around a circular synthesiser motif, soaring vocals and delicate cymbal work. The cavernous snare echos and glacial sheets of synth in ‘Only The Wind Can Hear You’ contains shades of O Soundtrack’s dense closing track, ‘My Heart Like Marching Band’.

At 38 minutes, Church is PVT’s shortest full-length yet, and while it’s not as immediately enjoyable as the last, the stylistic departures displayed here see them striving toward a sound they’re wholly comfortable with.

+

PVT’s Church With No Magic is out July 16 through Warp/Inertia.

  -   Published on Monday, July 12 2010 by Andrew McMillen.
Related Artists


Your Comments

NiteShok  said about 1 month ago:

So this is out now. Who likes it? Who doesn't?


tinyman  said about 1 month ago:

few brief listens. i'm impressed. maybe a bit kookier and sillier than they planned. but still interesting.


mirkheim  said 26 days ago:

Crimson Swan is killer, so the three song run of swan/window/quick mile is good stuff.

Having said that, the rest of the album doesn't quite hold my attention so much; but I'll give it some time and a few more listens.


spruik  said 26 days ago:

the wire hated on it pretty hard. review contained the word 'brrrrripoff'.

outrageous.


NiteShok  said 26 days ago:

Got a link, spruik? Or if it's not online, would you mind typing it out?


dub3000  said 26 days ago:

i like it. it's good.


labrish  said 26 days ago:

I'm pretty sure they included the phrase 'post dubstep bandwagon jumpers'.


shaun  said 26 days ago:

While by no means glowing, the review isn't that negative either. I think it's pretty spot on.


runoutgroove  said 26 days ago:

I agree shaun, I didn't read it as super negative.


spruik  said 26 days ago:

Much of Church With No Magic, the latest album by the trio formerly known as Pivot, feels like a desperate stab at kudos. LIke they've trawled Pitchfork fir the latest buzz tropes, then beefed them up for the stadium crowd.

''Light Up Bright Fires'' fleshes out a Wiley-ish skeletal grime lop with gated drums and a lairy sawtooth bassline; the title track cuts facsimile Alan Vega vocals with a chilly, coldwave synth hook.

Brrrrrip-off.

Funnily enough, PVT are best when they ride against prevailing fashions. As on ''Window'', whose bullish keys and football chant chorus recalls the unabashed power-sleaze of the Backstreet Boys' ''Everybody (Backstreet's back)''.

Maybe if PVT stopped trying to be 'experimental' and delivered some decent hooks, they could be a great pop group.

--

which is ironic, cos O Soundtrack was relatively hook-laden, I reckon.


runoutgroove  said 26 days ago:

i guess there have been very few reviews in the wire that mention both pitchfork and backstreet boys.


spruik  said 25 days ago:

the writer sounds as though he's mildly disgusted and amused in equal measure.


Arthurly  said 25 days ago:

I'm chosing the right to remain silent on this album.


NiteShok  said 20 days ago:

Carbie Warbie has some nice close-quarters footage of the band playing 'Church With No Magic' at The Corner on Thursday night: http://vimeo.com/14102041


You need to be logged into Mess+Noise to contribute to the Releases.
Go on and Log In or if you you're not a member, feel free to Sign Up.

Tracklisting
  • 1.   Community
  • 2.   Light Up Bright Fires
  • 3.   Church With No Magic
  • 4.   Crimson Swan
  • 5.   Window
  • 6.   The Quick Mile
  • 7.   Waves and Radiation
  • 8.   Circle Of Friends
  • 9.   Timeless
  • 10.   Only The Wind Can Hear You
Related M+N Content
Today On Mess+Noise