View the Mobile Version of M+N

Record Reviews
Sleep

Romy
Sleep

4 Track, Single (2010, Independent)
Play All Tracks In New Window
Related: Macromantics, Romy.


With 2006's Moments in Movement (recorded under former moniker Macromantics) and its accompanying explanations, you could say we were amply forewarned. At the time, most interviews with the then 26-year-old Romy Hoffman hinted at a restless and provocative musical sensibility that wouldn't be confined to any one style for long. Harder to stomach, perhaps, would be the notion that the indie hip-hop firebrand's lyrical snarl would find a new home in one of the world's least eloquent genres: disco.

‘Sleep’ is an upbeat dancefloor kicker, playing a straight beat off against plucky 909 rimshots and fat, buzzing bass stabs. Paying homage to the modern Italo Disco revival is the eerie quiver of a chorused synthesiser, the likes of which could easily have been lifted from Glass Candy's ‘Life After Sundown’, or a bad tele-movie about ghosts. (Those familiar with boutique label Italians Do It Better will recognise similarity to Johnny Jewel's favoured "mysterious arpeggio".) When the vocals kick in, two or three Romys (Romies?) sing diva-like about the usual stuff: mirror balls, love, dancing and how late at night it is. The track is strongest in its climax, where the song's “Intense” feeling surges to something resembling “Dramatic”.

While the single is no slouch tempo-wise, autumnal DJs are more likely to be spinning its remix by The Juan Maclean. The track has a compelling, spacious bounce, punctuated by string stabs and twinkles: allusions to early 1990s commercial house chart hits. Its dissonant, stilted delivery is memorable on repeat listens, only occasionally in a bad way – with its repetition of slices of Romy's vocals (“Teach me, teach me, teach me, teach me”, and so on).

The song receives yet another reworking courtesy of Brain Children, which sounds like poor old John Cougar Mellencamp's ‘Jack and Diane’ sped up for the modern age. Nostalgic synth noodling and Moog-ish bass round out the arrangement, which loses its beat halfway and ultimately sounds like the kind of song you'd hear over the end credits of a film that ends happily.

But it's not all about happy endings. ‘Love Is Life’ breaks the feeling of resolution with cutting synth pop and a bassline that squirts and quavers with pulsing conviction. A melancholy descending melody cuts through a sea of chirping keys while Romy sings her verses through a fog thick with delay and the memory of ESG's Scroggins sisters.

With only two of the single's four tracks produced by Hoffman herself – and those two vastly different – it's difficult to estimate with any certainty whether her production can match the innovative quality of former collaborator Buchman. There is a sense that the songs could benefit from more dynamism; then again, these tight and loud numbers will sound good on the radio. What is clear on ‘Sleep’ is that Romy handles the challenges of MCing better than those of her ambitious melodies. There's something a bit off about her delivery; falling short of some notes, overshooting others. And at other times, it feels as though she's still spitting things out a bit harshly; remnants of her former life, perhaps?

Regardless, there's little more interesting than watching artists shift direction – and Romy's metamorphosis will be one worth observing.

by Babette Gladney

Related Artists


Your Comments

black wasp!  said about 1 year ago:

Slightly baffling song. I kinda hate the chorus but the rest is alright, eh?


Jackbratt  said about 1 year ago:

Macro is back! swoon


anok  said about 1 year ago:

been keen to hear this new stuff for a while.

nice review. sounds informed.


tvforcats  said about 1 year ago:

not a fan at all, and I quite liked macromantics and production.


anok  said about 1 year ago:

it's so INYOURFACEINTENSE. don't like it.


tinyman  said about 1 year ago:

oh dear. do not like.


MATTPHEONIXxoxoxo  said about 1 year ago:

I dig it. But i like to disco.


SpringRain  said about 1 year ago:

i like the idea of people making good, fun dance music... but a lot of this stuff all sounds the same and lacks strong character/originality. the label mentioned in the review is really samey and boring. but i suppose it doesn't matter too much. it's just dance music


anok  said about 1 year ago:

what do you mean ''it's just dance music''?

like a lot of labels, IDIB has some greatness and plenty of not-so-greatness. it's pretty hard to be great, i think.


SpringRain  said about 1 year ago:

not much


tig  said about 1 year ago:

It sounds a bit nova dance to me, will do well with the kids i reckon. It's a long way from traditional disco though.


tig  said about 1 year ago:

Dance music has a lot of meaning to many people, it has distinct and continuing socio-political underpinning that's often lost on Rock critics.

I wonder if that's why Romy decided to foray into it...


lawson  said about 1 year ago:

Babette's ''rock critical'' knowledge is intimidatingly deep. Great review.


MATTPHEONIXxoxoxo  said about 1 year ago:

let it breathe


timewaster  said about 1 year ago:

I think it's good.

Well produced. It's been mixed well. The keyboard break is reminiscent of Glass Candy / Chromatics, but that's a good thing.

Hard to predict if it'll do well. It's so hard to predict ANYTHING in music these days.

But I like the song. Producing a good disco track is harder than 'rock' people think.


Tango Whiskeyman  said about 1 year ago:

world's least eloquent genres - disco
i try and avoid spilling my brain on this site, but that statement hurts.
glass candy are not the only people to have released any 'disco' in the last 2 decades. I'll never understand how their album made it onto every i-pod, but i guess it's definitely one step forward

disco is an attitude and a way of listening and approaching music, not one style or genre. More importantly, there is a very very passionate and intelligent community of people into DISCO. It's super exciting that people are pursuing it locally. i will be quite now.


untold/animals  said about 1 year ago:

world's least eloquent genres - disco
i try and avoid spilling my brain on this site, but that statement hurts.

I took that part as kind of a joke! I mean, as tig says, it's obvious that every genre has its own set of cues and secondary/implied meanings, feelings and codes - I don't think anybody would ever assert that people who listen to Rock are dealing with a different emotional range to those listening to Jazz or whatever.

I imagine what's being said here is merely that Romy is going from freestyling really verbose verses and yammering about stealing dudes' girlfriends to singing fairly simplistic lines in that kinda detached way that some modern dance tracks favour. It's probably more about the contrast than anything intrinsic to disco... it would be pretty rich of any critic to dismiss a genre so readily, especially when they seem to have some kind of interest in it.


untold/animals  said about 1 year ago:

Producing a good disco track is harder than 'rock' people think.

I agree but I don't really think this song works, for me at least. I do think tig is right - Nova will probably lap it up!


untold/animals  said about 1 year ago:

And Romy did say in that other interview that she's been thinking about how she can work hard and make a living off of music, so... maybe we're not the target audience anyway!


semblance  said about 1 year ago:

I'd be interested to hear this....her effort at hip hop in 2006 was pretty spectacular in a good and bad way


untold/animals  said about 1 year ago:

I'd be interested to hear this

Errr. There is a play button up the top!


neopleuromasterdon  said about 1 year ago:

having listened to this song,

I think it sux

thanks


Tango Whiskeyman  said about 1 year ago:

agreed, totally, just a knee jerk reaction to 'disco' being used as a dirty word.


black wasp!  said about 1 year ago:

From an article by Guy Blackman in The Age a few years ago:

Of course, Hoffmann also has eyes on bigger prizes. ''At the moment I reach an audience - that kind of punk-indie audience,'' she acknowledges. ''I know they all get it and I appreciate that, but I do want to take it further.''

She loves mainstream R'n'B and wonders whether she could strike a balance between authenticity and commercial appeal.

''I really want to work out the right formula for that,'' Hoffmann says. ''No one's ever going to tell me what to wear or how to look, but there is some compromise in order to make it to that level.''


Tramdriver  said about 1 year ago:

^Well at least she is honest. I agree with untold Nova will lap it up (I'm merely indifferent).


SpringRain  said about 1 year ago:

indie is a dirtier word than disco


black wasp!  said about 1 year ago:

with its repetition of slices of Romy's vocals (“Teach me, teach me, teach me, teach me”, and so on)

That's funny, it sounds to me like it says ''Teach me''/''Eat me''. Creepy/sexy!


anok  said about 1 year ago:

weirdo


nishiki  said about 1 year ago:

i like dance music (to a degree) but i wasn't totally sold on this. lyrics are patchy; hook is ok but verses are boring. the production isn't great. babette's on the money i reckon.


tugboat  said about 1 year ago:

Romy!


tvforcats  said about 1 year ago:

You know what, i think i might like it now.......


CaptainHowdy  said about 1 year ago:

ohh man! i'm so excited about this release. where can i buy it?


shunt  said about 1 year ago:

Tango Whiskeyman  said about 1 year ago:

woke up with the hook totally on loop in my head... that's a good thing.
so excited about this release. where can i buy it? The single edit is on I-Tunes for sale, not the remix's though.


black wasp!  said about 1 year ago:

Ah crap. It's growing on me a bit!


anok  said about 1 year ago:

if peeps wanna hear the juan remix you can do so here at RCRDLBL.


CaptainHowdy  said about 1 year ago:

i wanna hear ''love is life''.


parsleypenelope  said about 1 year ago:

i like it. romy is amazing. its super catchy.


tugboat  said about 1 year ago:

From the New War Thread:

saintfelony said 11 minutes ago:
new war w/ romy (mems. macromantics, my disco etc) & clymatron (tom from devastations) tonight at bar open - 9pm. FREE. set times: clymatron 9:30, romy 10:15, new war 11pm. cheers


tugboat  said about 6 months ago:

I JUST FUCKEN REALIZE SHE IS PLAYING TMR!

http://www.facebook.com/pages/ROMY/362328152266#!/event.php?eid=113632605392781

fucken crash with The Laurels though!


Goal attack  said about 6 months ago:

Did she find her wider audience?


tugboat  said about 6 months ago:

^^^ ?


tugboat  said about 6 months ago:

Bump for tonight


____  said about 6 months ago:

Just heard this for the first time, and it's the most repulsive thing i've heard in years, lucky it's from a year ago. She's better than this, right?


CaptainHowdy  said about 6 months ago:

does romy perform songs she recorded as macromantics?


tugboat  said about 6 months ago:

Her rap stuff is better than singing stuff. It is like a reverse Catcall.


CaptainHowdy  said about 6 months ago:

i don't mind romy's singing. this sounds pretty good.


tugboat  said about 6 months ago:

I like it but rap stuff is better. Still thinking if I should go to Laurels or her gig...


CaptainHowdy  said about 5 months ago:

Romy Hoffman: BLACKLUSTRE
Exhibition: 1-10 September 2011
Opening Celebrations: 6-8pm Thursday 1 September 2011

BLACKLUSTRE is a celebration of black thinkers and culture in today's pop world. BLACKLUSTRE is also an investigation of otherness, minorities and white guilt. Romy Hoffman is a singing songstress and sonic composer, who likes to rant and rave. When she isn't making music, the artist obsessively jots and draws, doodles and documents. Romy Hoffman makes up her own jokes and illustrates them; she is, literally, a word play artist. This is her second solo exhibition at NO NO GALLERY: in 2010 she showed almost 100 drawings completed in the space of only one week.


untold/animals  said about 5 months ago:

mein gott


untold/animals  said about 5 months ago:

teach me teach me teach me teach me teach me teach me teach me


monoceros  said about 5 months ago:

What happened to Macromantics?


You need to be logged into Mess+Noise to contribute to the Releases.
Go on and Log In or if you you're not a member, feel free to Sign Up.

Tracklisting
  • 1.   Sleep
  • 2.   Sleep (The Juan Maclean remix)
  • 3.   Sleep (Brian Children remix)
  • 4.   Love Is Life
Related M+N Content
Today On Mess+Noise