View the Mobile Version of M+N

Discussions

Fairy Tales

P-joanie  said about 5 years ago  or at  11:41PM on Friday, March 2 2007 in books

I've been reading lots of fairy tales. My favourite are the Grimms Bros.

Rapunzel, Little Matchstick Girl, The Bremen Town Musicians are all excellent but the best is the one about the Tailor who killed seven flies with one blow and then was so proud he made himself a sash to wear that read: Seven With One Blow.

Any favourites ?


kcor  said about 5 years ago:

The pages were normal paper but the pictures were on shiny paper. I'd flick through to find the shiny pages and look at the pictures for hours. So much magic in a golden pear.


P-joanie  said about 5 years ago:

You sound like you dont read them anymore. or flick through to the shiny pages anymore


moses  said about 5 years ago:

i love myths, legends, fairytales

i recommend this

http://www.amazon.com/Italian-Folktales-Italo-Calvino/dp/0156454890


P-joanie  said about 5 years ago:

That looks great moses. I love these tales. I'dlike to know where each story originates from. I love the language!

Apperently Cinderalla is originally from China.

They're always so dark these tales


dork  said about 5 years ago:

"fairy tales" in their original form rule. But the sanitised crap in Disney books is just awful and gives kids an unrealistic expectation of the real world.


P-joanie  said about 5 years ago:

Yeah yeah everyone hates Disney but even some of those early cartoon fairy tale features are pretty scary. Much more violence in the traditional books though. I always like a good woodsman who knows how to use an axe. A lot of the tales seem to be warnings against curiosity in children.

I was just thinking about that recent movie The Bros Grimm and what a shame it is that it's meant to be really shit. Anyone seen it? Is it actually ok? : o


goldfoot  said about 5 years ago:

The Seven Chinese Brothers struck a chord with me when I was a kid. Does anyone have a copy I could borrow? I'd like to read it again.


MountainMan  said about 5 years ago:

i like fairy tales and folk stories. some of the illustrators have been excellent too, over the years.
check this out by ivan bilibin of the russian witch baba yaga:


MountainMan  said about 5 years ago:


PaulsGrandfather  said about 5 years ago:

That's awesome, MM.

The Bros. Grimm movie does kind of suck. It's not horrible but it's pretty average. There's an annoying 'love interest' in it, too, played by this chick who obviously got the role because Keira Knightly wasn't interested.


littlearch  said about 5 years ago:

charles de lint is a great modern fairy tale teller

i have a large collection of his novels if you'd like to borrow them, peony


P-joanie  said about 5 years ago:

I'd love to have a read rach.
Hey M.M those drawings are beautiful! Anything illustrated by Michael Foremen is also good.

I want to visit the black forest and see real castles. Once upon a time.....


juicenewton*  said about 5 years ago:

I love Baba Yaga, and Hans Christian Anderson is also great.

I'd go Authur Rackingham 1

Michael Haugue for illustrations


juicenewton*  said about 5 years ago:

Hey !

Arthur Rackham I mean.....



MountainMan  said about 5 years ago:

rackham is great, juice! those alice in wonderland illustrations were magnificent.

another great illustrator is warwick goble:


MountainMan  said about 5 years ago:


MountainMan  said about 5 years ago:

and of course, there's brian froud:


MountainMan  said about 5 years ago:


BADALEX  said about 5 years ago:

"and the secret of fire was lost upon the battlefield to be found by not gods, not giants, but men. Just men."


september  said about 5 years ago:

the princess and the pea and rumpelstiltzkin. imagine how quickly the miller's daughter could have found out his name if she'd googled a few choice words.

i'm reading italio calvino's italian folktales at the moment too. there was one about a man who would give his daughter's hand in marriage to the first man who could give her her fill of figs. figs!


MountainMan  said about 5 years ago:

figs are a very sensual fruit. so sensual in fact, that the french will only eat them with knives and forks, as devouring a fruit with one's hands is considered vulgar. because figs are like vadges.


imaginarylion  said about 5 years ago:

Does the Decameron count as fairy tales? I can read them over and over again.. the perfect mix of fantasy, tragedy, comedy and sex. I wonder if they were all having orgies in the villa after storytime was over for the day?


Belle  said about 5 years ago:

I am right into my Enid Blyton Fairaway Tree series again... I am about to start The Enchanted Wood.


Belle  said about 5 years ago:

oops spelling - Faraway Tree!


MountainMan  said about 5 years ago:

someone was telling me to read the decameron. is it like an italian 'canterbury tales'?


imaginarylion  said about 5 years ago:

I've never read the Canterbury Tales... the basic premise of the Decameron is that a group of young men and women have fled the city because of the plague, and they're holed up in a villa in the countryside. To pass the time each one tells a story each day.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Decameron


MountainMan  said about 5 years ago:

looks good. i like reading about the plague.


JunkiePhil  said about 4 years ago:

I'm going to share a little somthing I just pondered.
You know how back in ye old'e times, chicks were always getting kidnaped and put in towers and shit, so that a Knight would have to come and save them.
You know, like a princess in a tower, that a evil man has locked away?
That kind of deal,
Anywho, I was just thinking, that they always make out as thought the chick in the tower is fine when the prince arives, and that her only problem was being locked in the room, Well I've decided that all I've learnt from Fairy Tales is a load of shit.
Those tower chicks would have basicaly been Gimps for these evil tyrants.
Basicaly, I do think the fairy tales have enough rape in them.


september  said about 4 years ago:

hmmmm, quite often it's chicks putting other chicks in towers or open coffins or putting spells on spinning wheels. beware the evil step mother i say. dudes in fairy tales are usually busy filling their pockets.


katiepotatie  said about 4 years ago:

i was thinking about this recently, in terms of romance.

the only fairy tale relationships i can think of involve the girl getting out said tower/coffin/etc then living happily ever after with her knight in shining armour. are they really all like this?


september  said about 4 years ago:

love is somehow sweeter when it triumphs over adversity. who'd waste their time reading about a couple who met under the swinging udder of the cow they were milking and went on to lives together without serious incident.


AlterEgo  said about 4 years ago:

for some reason what you just said september made me think of tess of the d'urbervilles. definitely not a fairy tale, that one.


september  said about 4 years ago:

good old misery guts hardy.


moses  said about 4 years ago:

therea couple of other really popular scenarios

girl runs away with guy (from evil stepmother?)

girl needs to save her brothers/family

dont forget the king killing his wicked wife by rolling her down a hill in a barrel full of nails. always my favourite part.


katiepotatie  said about 4 years ago:

what?! where is the barrel of nails story from?? wow.. thats, er, extreme.

i get the reason for overcoming the adversities, but i'm more wondering if there are any fairy tales that dont end ''happily ever after'', which is also supposed to be a compulasory part of the formula....


katiepotatie  said about 4 years ago:

oops that was supposed to be italic not *bold*


katiepotatie  said about 4 years ago:

haha... or bold italic as the case may be


JunkiePhil  said about 4 years ago:

Are any of the famous fairy tales based on true storys / accounts ?


september  said about 4 years ago:

i think the message in most fairy tales is being really good looking is pretty handy when you're in a fix.


AlterEgo  said about 4 years ago:

i dont think they did always end up happily ever after katiepotatie - hansel and gretel where meant to be eaten by the witch, red riding hood got eaten too, and sleeping beauty died an old hag in her tower.

wasn't the whole point of fairy tales to scare the shit out of naughty kids to make them behave?


JunkiePhil  said about 4 years ago:

Exactly, not that people base their lives around these tales, but it gives the impression that if you are pretty and in trouble, you'll be saved in no time, and come out of it with out a scratch.
Not the case in real life.


AlterEgo  said about 4 years ago:

where = were



katiepotatie  said about 4 years ago:

nooo! i thought sleeping beauty got rescued!

oh well. the point ive arrived at i think is pretty much in keeping with you guys - in particular in regards to romantic love - is that fairy tales would have believe you fall in love and get over some hurdle and everything is perfect. in life = not so. this is for an essay i have to write, and just thought i'd check if were any exceptions to the rule before i write 2500 words on it and find out i was wrong as i havent read that many....


Manhattan  said about 4 years ago:

My favourites were King Midas, Blue Beard, The Pied Piper of Hamlyn, and a bunch of Hans Christian Anderson that I no longer remember the titles of, but there was one that stood out - a peasant boy who was on a boat in an underwater cave that was chock full of jewels.

AND - if you can tell me what this is, I'll be very excited. A man sticking money to a tree - when someone walks passed and doesn't ask what he's doing, the man shakes the tree so some money falls down - he says ''you're the first person who hasn't asked why I'm doing this''. Then at the end, there's a girl (or was it a bee?!) who has such a keen sense of smell that she picked the only real flower in a room full of fakes. I think there was some kind of moral to this story, and if so, it was lost on me.


katiepotatie  said about 4 years ago:

haha alter i checked wiki on the weekend :p


JunkiePhil  said about 4 years ago:

Can you mention that the princess never gets sexualy abused in fairy tales, when in reality, she most probably would.


littlearch  said about 4 years ago:

thing is junkiephil is that it is simply suggested that she is being abused so as not to scare the children, read between the lines


AlterEgo  said about 4 years ago:

um katie - there are so many different versions of fairy tales. i'm pretty sure that i read one where sleeping beauty isn't rescued, but if you wanted to say that in an essay, you'd have to say who wrote that version down. fairy tales were originally campfire tales, or bedside tales, and weren't put in to written form for ages apparently. (damn wikipedia is good!)


JunkiePhil  said about 4 years ago:

Yeah, I guess.
I'm just not satisfied with the way the pictures depict the princess at the end.
She always looks like she's been at beauty camp.
Not booty camp for evil tyrants.


katiepotatie  said about 4 years ago:

my childhood was a lie! i thought it was commonly accepted that she lived :( haha


AlterEgo  said about 4 years ago:

maybe you should read books that don't have pictures in them?


katiepotatie  said about 4 years ago:

hey! better late than never...


AlterEgo  said about 4 years ago:

that was a x-post katie! i didn't mean you! reading the wiki is making me want to get back into reading mythology and stuff again. it's so interesting!

did you think about mythology at all for your essay? there's probably quite a few myths that are also fables / fairy tales. like the one about Achilles....


andydepressant  said about 4 years ago:

anyone know the story of volund?

It's pretty funny how all the old mythologies spread like herpes and no-one knows who started it. Volund is supposed to relate all the way back to Odin but his story resembles daedelus and icarus' flight past minos which is greek rather than norse.

I love the way the sense of justice in the much older tales is so utterly foreign. Look up lammikin. He was a tradie that didn't get paid so he slaughtered his clients wife and child and left him alive. Yeh that'll teach him!


AlterEgo  said about 4 years ago:

yeah that's the kind of fairy tale i was thinking of andy. the ones where you get taught a lesson


moses  said about 4 years ago:

what?! where is the barrel of nails story from?? wow.. thats, er, extreme.

the barrell of nails is in probably 5 or 6 stories from brothers grimm and maybe a couple from calvino's italian folktales. different bits of stories constantly intermingle so its like a familiar motif.

theyre often quite violent though. in the brothers grimm version of cinderella, two ravens pluck out the eyes of the evil stepsisters.


katiepotatie  said about 4 years ago:

i have been thinking about myths etc too, same but different i guess.
im looking at romeo & juliet, orpheus & eurydice etc as tragedies at the other end of the scale, where they all die, instead of ''living happily ever after'' they have a love which shines brightly, but not for long.


sister  said about 4 years ago:

i saw a picture of a barrel of nails the other day.

hmmm. a tv guide perhaps?


AlterEgo  said about 4 years ago:

sounds cool! can i read it when you're finished?


You need to be logged into Mess+Noise to contribute to the Discussions.
Go on and Log In or if you you're not a member, feel free to Sign Up.

Today On Mess+Noise
MESS+NOISE on Facebook

The M+N Newsletter

Sign up for special offers, giveaways and exclusive tracks. The best spam you'll ever receive.