View the Mobile Version of M+N

Featured Articles

Recording Cat Power

In 1998 Melbourne native Matt Voigt was working as an assistant engineer at Melbourne's Sing Sing studios. When he got a call asking if he'd come in to record an American woman over the next week or so, like any other offer of engineering work he blithely accepted. In the next 5 days he'd record, produce and mix the seminal Moon Pix, a record that was a landmark for one of rock's most compelling yet awkward stars. MARCUS TEAGUE reports.

Chan Marshall fully delivered on the promise of her debut two years later when she released her magnum opus Moon Pix, a true masterpiece of emotional shading and compositional clarity. Recorded in Australia with her friends from the Dirty Three, guitarist Mick Turner and drummer Jim White, the album continuously impresses with complex, deeply expressive arrangements that manage to be nostalgic, even sentimental, but still strikingly contemporary, without ever feeling contrived. From the heavy backwards drum loop of the plaintive opener, "American Flag," through the flute trills of "He Turns Down" and the raindrops of "Say," there's a boldness, a willingness to try all sorts of stylistic innovation without fear, that results in dazzling variation between songs even as the album overall feels satisfyingly cohesive. A big part of the cohesion comes thanks to Marshall's unique singing voice, which is sexy and resigned and rough all at once, an immense world of joy and hurt lying behind it like life beneath the surface of a lake. -

Matt: The day before New Year's Eve I got a phone call in the afternoon from the studio. They said "This American lady popped into the studio and wants to do an album...can you start work on New Year's Day?" And I said "Fuck no not on New Year's Day. (Laughs) Let's do it the next day."

I'd worked at Sing Sing for six or seven years, just as one of their in-house guys. I knew nothing of Cat Power except that she wanted to record on New Year's Day and that was out of the question. I didn't know anything about her at all, so we organized to start on the second of January. I turned up and met Chan. She got her guitar out and I said "Ok let's set a mic up...what do you wanna do? And we just started recording.

What were the circumstances of how she came to be at Sing Sing in Melbourne on New Years Day?

I found out later that she got a record company advance and was travelling. And I think she spent a lot of the money on her travelling. She ended up in Australia cause she was friends with the Dirty 3, and then realised "Oh my god I've gotta provide the record label with an album... what am I gonna do?" So she turned up to the studio and was you know, "Give me 4 or 5 days I need to do this album". And the Dirty 3 were going to help her out.

How did the first few days go?

So it started off and she came in and said "I want a backwards drum beat." She had a Beastie Boys cd or something like that in her bag and I can't remember which song it was, but we got one of the drum beats and flipped it around backwards. Cut it up a bit and put a drum beat in there, just some random thing. And she goes "Oh ok that's cool" and then she started recording American Flag on top of that. And it was very loose...but I think that was part of the charm.

Was she playing and singing at the same time?


And this was in Sing Sing South?

No Sing Sing Richmond, the main one. We had a little amp in one room, her sitting in another room with a microphone. I think it was an M49 valve microphone. And I had a lovely Fairchild 660 compressor on there, going through a 1073 Neve Mic Pre. And it just sounded beautiful. She sang and it was like "Oh my god." She's got a creamy voice.

What was your impression of her as she began?

She was fine, a lovely lady. Very emotional. We would do takes and she'd just start crying in the middle of a take. And she'd say "Stop, stop, I'm sorry, I'm sorry" and I'm like "It sounded great!"

What was she crying about?

I don't know, she just gets upset. I think she's very hard on herself and...I mean with her voice you hear all the emotion that she puts in to her singing. She just feels it a lot. But I didn't intrude. Accept her for who she is and that's fantastic and I'm recording it and I'm here to make her happy and that's it.

She's well known for being a somewhat shambolic live performer, and I guess some people have wondered whether it's partly her 'schtick'?

Not at all, that's just her. She's just very emotional. I found it unusual that she would stop and get annoyed with herself. I didn't understand why because she sounded so good. But it wasn't mine to ask why, it's mine to support her and just tell her that everything's alright...lets do another take cause it's sounding great.

Did The Dirty 3 come in after she'd done her parts?

I think they came in on the second day. Chan laid done some guitars and vocals and then Jim came in and did some drums just on top of those. And there were another two songs I think where she did it live with Jim and Mick and we got a bass player (Andrew Entsch) in playing double bass. And we did 2 songs live that way with them and they were great. Easy to get along with, just in and out.

Were they maybe looking after her in a way?

Jim did help her a lot in organising the whole thing, you know he introduced her to the studio. I think they also did a whole lot of demos before they came in down at Jim's house in his bathroom. And actually one of those songs got on the album, and that's Peking Saint. I think he also helped with a few suggestions on parts and song structure. But mainly it was Chan.

On Crossbones Style...

That was a funny one. She did the guitars for that but because she doesn't play to a click, and sort've does her own thing....she wanted Jim to come in and play drums on top. Jim's gotta just follow her as best he can. So sometimes there were bits where he'd go slightly out of time because Chan was sort've moving around (timing wise).

Is that why there's a lot of delay and reverb?

In the mixdown process we decided we were going to try some delay on the drums to sort've funk it up a bit. I'd wind in the delay sometimes on the drums when it started to get really out of time.

So though it came about because of a mistake really, it ends up making the song sound quite...

Charming. Yeah.

One of the things that's interesting about this is that Moon Pix for her was really her breakthrough record. And that song and that video were the reason why. At what point did you come to understand, if at all, her background?

Towards the end of the session we had a conversation about "Where did you write the songs, and y'know what's that song about?" And she said that she had just been in Mexico. She'd found inspiration and had written pretty much most of the album there in a week. At least that was my understanding. Some of the songs are about her say, meeting God. And will God let her into heaven.

Did she seem very religious?

No, no I think she just had an epiphany. About life. And maybe she had a lot of Peyote I don't know (laughs). It's Mexico!

Did she record anything that didn't go on there?

There was one song that we tried to record that I thought was fantastic. But she had real trouble doing the vocal for it because it was so different to what she was used to doing, the way she was singing. Because it was a different meter from how the song was originally intended. So that was one that I thought was fantastic but she never finished.

In the mixing process, in the first or second song I was asking "Ok so how's it sounding to you?" And she's going "Good but's kind of..." And she couldn't put it into words. So she grabbed a piece of paper and just drew a circle. Round and round in a circle so many times. And I was like (pause) "Ok cool" (Laughs) So I took that as meaning it's too compressed. So I backed off the compression a bit and just made it a little bit more open, cause I think I'd wound too much on there. It sounded more open, more dynamic. And she was happy.

Did you follow the album once it came out?

It was such a whirlwind 5 days and then the album was whisked away. She disappeared and went back to New York and I think I was a bit nervous. I mean I didn't have any copies of the mixes I did for myself. And I thought "Oh god I don't know what it's going to sound like." I think it was mastered in Sterling Sound in New York and they did a fantastic job, and afterwards Matador sent me a couple of cd's. And I loved it. Thought it sounded great.

Have you paid her much attention since?

I've seen her a few times in concert. Really love her in concert. I saw her in New York, I happened to be over there and she was playing a gig. I was lucky enough to drop my name at the door cause it was a sold out performance, and someone spoke to her and let me in which was nice. Caught up with her backstage

And how was the show?

It was great it was classic Cat Power. A room packed full of people that wee really silent and ready to hear what she had to say. She performed well, I think she stopped one or two songs and started saying "I'm sorry I'll start that one again." But y'know it's a moment in time and it's a performance where she captures her feelings and expressions and that's that.

What'd you learn from the experience?

That it's not about me it's about the artist. And I kinda learnt to not be too hard on mysef. Cause I could see her being so hard on herself and it was unnecessary cause it was great. And we all tend to be a bit hard and a bit down on ourselves sometimes and you've just gotta try not to be. Because chances are you're not so bad.

Since making Moon Pix Matt has gone on to work with the likes of Kiss, The Dirty 3, Powderfinger, The Living End, Warped, Augie March, Deloris and Black Level Embassy, as well as a stint over in Turkey working with traditional musicians and the odd cheeseball pop singer. He continues to work at Sing Sing and locally.


  -   Published on Saturday, March 25 2006 by Marcus Teague.
Related Artists

Your Comments

whosgotthecrack?  said about 8 years ago:

I really loved this article, marcus

semblance  said about 8 years ago:

Geez, I can't believe people haven't made more comments about this. This album is phenomenal
And this article is a flattering and intimate portrait of a ...ahem...troubled genius. Sam

tugboat  said about 2 years ago:

I love this article.

easternsuburbanite  said about 2 years ago:

Interesting. I remember reading an interview with Jim White on the same recording session where he was having to push Matt pretty hard to accept Chan's ideas, and the whole process was fairly difficult for them all.
Either way, the record came out a masterpiec.

whatwhat  said about 2 years ago:

Never seen this article before today.

Tres good!

goingblank  said about 2 years ago:

You haven't got a link to that article, have you ES?

easternsuburbanite  said about 2 years ago:

It might have been in Beat or Inpress back in the day...or even in the old Punter's Club ''Form Guide''. I'd have to go searching, but I definately remember Jim being a driving force in the studio, as Chan didn't have the confidence to push her ideas.

dalmanac  said about 2 years ago:

Yes, it was from an Anthony Carew interview published in Beat on Jan 6 1999... question and answer between Carew and Marshall as follows:

AC: So were you essentially 'the producer', as such?
CM: Oh, absolutely, it was just me and the engineer. I begged Jim White to come in there, because I was afraid to sit in the room with the engineer because I didn't know him. So Jim kind of sat there reading gossip magazines - y'know, like Courtney Love, bullshit like that: rock stuff, gossip stuff; he'd just be reading that, telling me all that stuff. And if the engineer did something I didn't like, I'd be like: ''why'd you do that? I don't like that'; and the engineer might say: 'I did that because of this reason, and because of this reason we have to that.' And Jim would kind of just appear from out of the couch, and he'd be like: 'why are you doing that? She said she didn't like it, so why are you doing it?'; so it was like, every now and then Jim would help me with my confidence. It was great, too, because the engineer at the end - after I had been basically running the show with no idea of how to get what I wanted...
AC: You had no conceived goal, no masterplan laid down, right...
CM: No, no masterplan. I had an idea of what I wanted, but all of my flip-flopping drove the engineer crazy. The impulsiveness - 'I want to do this' - that drove him insane.

buffytufnel  said about 2 years ago:

Around the same time she came down to 3CR to perform a few songs live to air on Burning Vinyl. I was presenting and Lotti Stein was the engineer. She burst into tears in the middle of the second song, live on radio, so I threw to a cart and asked if she wanted to stop. To cut a long story short, I put a long song on and we went outside and smoked a joint and then went across to the pub for a beer, the whole time I just left a cd playing out on the radio show. She was upset because three people she knew had just died in unrelated incidents. One was Andrew Entsch. She was a mess, and it feel upon me to comfort her. But after a beer and a smoke to my surprise she wanted to go back and finish the performance, so we went back into the studio and she did another song. People listening at home would've been scratching their heads wondering what the hell was going on, but she nailed that last track. Nobody has heard these songs unless they were listening to Burning Vinyl that day (or a few years ago when I played them again), but all up she did three (including a very early version of A Good Woman) each being of release-quality, but that's why you should listen to community radio, because stuff like that only happens once and then you never hear it again. Burning Vinyl - pioneering FOMO. The other thing I remember most about that day is that Chan is hot. Not shy, indie, cute - more like stunning movie star sexy. Sunny day at the beach sexy. I wasn't totally expecting that, but there you have it.

buffytufnel  said about 2 years ago:

feel = fell. Freudian slit.

tugboat  said about 2 years ago:

Fuck. I wish I was you. Can you gmail it?

tugboat  said about 2 years ago:

Hang on...Andrew Entsch died shortly after playing bass on moonpix?

silvertone  said about 2 years ago:

Yeah, he did, a day or so after his kid was born. A benefit concert was organised a few weeks later with the Dirty Three and friends, and two days before the benefit show at the Corner, the organiser of the benefit died. His wife got up on stage during the Dirty Three's set and lost her shit. What a fucked up mess of a night that was.

Don't do drugs kids.

silvertone  said about 2 years ago:

Andrew Nicholas Entsch

3 June 1965 - 5 December 1998

Special tribute program featuring recordings from the musical career of Andrew Entsch, PBS stalwart and presenter of PBS Live, and a couple of his favourite bands recorded live

Some of the bands Andrew played with:

  1. Kim Salmon & Friends - tba (10:10) Great Britain Hotel, Melbourne, 1991?, PBS recording
  2. Kim Salmon & STM - Hey Believer (3:39) ''Hey Believer'' CD, it was played by Kim Salmon at the wake 9Dec98
  3. Kim Salmon & Friends - Desensitised (8:54) Great Britain Hotel, Melbourne, 1991?, PBS recording
  4. King Idiot - Milk Bar (3:30) ''King Idiot'' CD, 'Live In Atlantis', Melbourne, Dec91
  5. King Idiot - Wally The Birdman (5:42) PBS ''Live In Your Lounge Room'', 11Sep90
  6. King Idiot - God (4:15) ''King Idiot'' CD, Andrew Entsch composition/vocals
  7. Matt Walker & Friends - Black Rose (3:55) ''Live At The Rainbow Hotel'' CD, Rainbow Hotel, Melbourne, 7Oct95
  8. Mighty Servant - What I Mean (2:58) ''There's Life'' CD, Andrew Entsch composition/vocals
  9. Matt Walker & Friends - This Broken Sky (5:38) ''Live At The Rainbow Hotel'' CD, Rainbow Hotel, Melbourne, 7Oct95
  10. Mighty Servant - Storm (5:00) ''There's Life'' CD
  11. Hood - Every Bell In Town (4:53) ''Every Bell In Town'' CD, it was played by Robin Casinader at the graveyard service 9Dec98
  12. Hood - Long Cigar (4:06) ''PBS Live'' 2Oct97, presented by Hugo Race as part of the Fringe Festival
  13. Sweet Young Corn - tba (?:??) from a demo tape
  14. Cat Power - He Turns Down (5:39) ''Moon Pix'' CD

Some other bands Andrew played with: Speil Azoi, Charlie Marshall & The Body Electric, Hose The Pig, Lewis Young & Friends.

A couple of Andrew's favourite artists:
15. Captain Beefheart - Peaches (6:04) ''London 1974'' CD, Theatre Royal, London, 9Jun74
16. Frank Zappa - Dickie's Such An Asshole (9:05) ''Kill Ugly Radio'' CD, also on ''You Can't Play That On Stage Anymore, Vol. 3'' 2CD
17. The Fall - Totally Wired (4:33) ''Live To Air Melbourne 82'' 2CD, Prince Of Wales Hotel, Melbourne, 2Aug82
18. The Fall - The Man Whose Head Expanded (5:22) ''Backdrop'' CD, originally from ''Bang Zoom'' tapezine issue 7
19. Velvet Underground - Heroin (8:14) ''1969 Live, Volume 1'' CD, San Francisco CA or Dallas TX, USA, late 1969

geneclark70  said about 2 years ago:

The details around Andrew Entsch's passing are so fucking sad. I played Moonpix this morning and told my girlfriend the sorry tale. She started crying, then punched me for telling such a tale of woe first thing in the morning.

silvertone  said about 2 years ago:

Yeah, I kinda feel shitting about posting what I did above. It was a horrible situation for anyone involved in that group of people. I'd only been living in Melbourne for a year, had know Chan from supporting her at the Sando the year before in Sydney. Very, very fucking sad.

You need to be logged into Mess+Noise to contribute to the Articles.
Go on and Log In or if you you're not a member, feel free to Sign Up.

Today On Mess+Noise